Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility Skip to Main Content
Montclair State University banner image

Biology

A guide to library research resources in biology.

What's the Difference?

Popular vs. Scholarly: What's the Difference?

Still having trouble telling the differences between popular and scholarly articles? Hopefully the following will help:

Popular, Scholarly, and Professional Sources

Your professors will often ask you to use scholarly sources for your assignments. A peer-reviewed article is one example of a scholarly source. However, professional scholars (academics) can, and often do, write authoritative articles in non-peer-reviewed journals and newspapers.

Popular, Scholarly, and Professional Sources
CATEGORY PURPOSE AUDIENCE AUTHORS CHARACTERISTICS LOCATION EXAMPLES
Popular & News

inform, persuade, or entertain;

Shape public opinion

General public.

Also influences policymakers & professionals.

Journalists – both professional & freelance – often shaped by Editorial Boards, Owners, & Advertisers

  • Easy-to-read language.
  • Few references or none
  • Short length
  • Advertisements
Google, news sites, library databases 

New York Times

Time Magazine

Scholarly

Grow and share academic knowledge;

Establish authority in a discipline

Researchers, professors, students

Academics, researchers – often tied to institutional or funding priorities

  • Structured (abstract, methods, references)
  • Lengthy
  • Peer-reviewed
  • Lots of references
  • Difficult to read
Google Scholar, library databases, institutional repositories

Journal of Sociology

Educational 
Researcher

Professional & Trade Share practical knowledge, trends, and issues within a field Practitioners, professionals, industry members

Practitioners, industry experts – who may be shaped by professional associations or commercial interests

  • Industry-specific language
  • Trade ads
  • Focus on applied practice.

 
Library databases, professional association websites, trade publishers

Women's Wear Daily

Variety

 

 

 

Friend, follow and subscribe to Sprague library!